Neutral by design. It names no party or official, and it judges no department.
The short version.
- Every public project can publish one short update on a schedule. The update says what changed and when.
- If nobody publishes, the page records "No update received" by itself. A missed update is a communication fact, not proof about the work.
- Records can be counted and grouped, so oversight bodies can see patterns. This is called a roll-up, and it ranks communication only.
- Anyone can rebuild the same view from the same public files. No one re-reports and there is no central database.
- Start with the habit, not the perfect update. Quality can be added slowly once updates arrive on time.
Where we left off
Our first article, published on 4 November 2026, asked every municipality and department to publish one short status update per public project. The update follows a fixed format, appears on a schedule and sits at one web address. If nobody publishes by the cut-off, the page records “No update received” by itself, and it does not repeat the old status as if it were current.
That article promised a follow-up. This is it. The first piece said that because every project publishes the same small record, the records add up. Here we explain what “add up” actually means, who can see what, and why the counting stops well short of judging the work itself.
What each person sees
A resident. You can see the latest plain-text update for a project near you, the date it was published and whether an update was missed. You can ask: “Is this project still being talked about, and when did we last hear something official?”
A councillor. You can see your municipality’s own updates, and also the dated comments the municipality adds beside projects owned by other levels of government. You can ask: “Which projects in my ward are owned elsewhere, and what has the owner said lately?”
A municipality. You can see your own projects, which updates went out on time and which were flagged. You can ask: “Where are we quiet, and who on our own ladder has been told?”
A district. You can see the projects of the local municipalities in the district, grouped together. You can ask: “Which local bodies are publishing steadily, and where are the gaps?”
A province. You can see the province-wide picture across its local-government department (often called COGTA, short for Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs) and its provincial departments. You can ask: “Which parts of our line are communicating, and which are not?”
A national department. You can see its own projects and those of its provincial counterparts. You can ask: “Where is our information thin across the country?”
The Department of Planning, Monitoring and Evaluation (DPME). DPME works under a Minister in the Presidency and supports planning, monitoring and evaluation across government. It sits at the top of each chain described below and can read the same public files anyone else can read. We make no claim about what it does with them internally.
The Presidency. The Presidency also sits at the top of the chains and can read the same public files. Again, we say nothing about its internal work.
Two different jobs: escalation and roll-up
Escalation is a nudge. One missed update goes to a named person on the owner’s own ladder, then to the next person, and so on. It is aimed at one project and one gap.
Roll-up is a tally. It counts and groups many projects so that people in oversight roles can see patterns. It creates no new reporting duty: it is built from the same records everyone can already read.
An everyday comparison: a library sends one late notice to one borrower. That is escalation. A manager counts how many notices went out across the whole branch last month, and groups them by section. That is roll-up. The second is built from the first, but it is a different job done for a different reader.
Who sits above whom
Here is the simplest honest picture: three chains, each ending at DPME and then the Presidency.
-
A ward project is owned by the local municipality, which sits in a district municipality. Above the district sit the provincial local-government (COGTA) department and the Office of the Premier. Above them sits the national COGTA department, then DPME, then the Presidency.
-
A provincial department’s project is owned by that department, through its Head of Department. Above it sits the Office of the Premier, then DPME, then the Presidency. National sector departments also have a line of sight to their provincial counterparts.
-
A national department’s or entity’s project is owned by the body itself, through its Director-General. Above that sits DPME, then the Presidency.
These chains show who can read whose public records. They are not a legal chain of command: formal accountability runs through ministers, MECs (the provincial members of the executive council), councils and legislatures, and each owner’s escalation ladder says who is told about a missed update.
Sideways from all of this, a municipality can add dated comments beside projects owned by other levels of government. A comment never changes the official status, never counts as the owner’s update and never clears a flag. Councillors can use these comments to see the provincial and national projects that residents hold them accountable for.
Rank the communication, never the delivery
The roll-up ranks one thing only: communication discipline. It looks at how many scheduled updates were received, normalised per project so that big and small bodies compare fairly. It also looks at how many days have passed since the last official word.
It never ranks delivery, progress or quality. The records simply do not prove those things. A quiet project may be doing excellent work. Its engineers may have signed off months ago, and the completion certificate may sit in a file that was never meant for public reading.
Silence is never evidence that work did not happen. A missed update is a fact about communication, not about the work. The ranking must make this impossible to misread, so it is built to say “we have not heard” rather than “nothing is happening”.
Start with communication, not perfection. First get updates appearing on time. Once that habit exists, improve what each update says, one small step at a time.
Try it: from the whole country down to one project
The demo below uses about 1,900 made-up projects: real department and province names, simulated figures. Every figure in it comes from a random number generator, which has no party, no vote and, as far as we can tell, no opinions.
Start on the map. Click a province to zoom in, switch layers on and off, and click a mark to open a project. The other tabs show how updates on time change over the days, how bodies and sectors compare, and how open flags climb the escalation ladders. Notice what the screen does and does not tell you.
Nobody has to re-report
Each body publishes a small public file that lists its projects. A daily job collects those files from every body that publishes. Nobody re-reports anything, and there is no central database. The files are the system, which is about as simple as a system gets.
Anyone can build the same view: a newsroom, a university, a council, a ward committee with a willing volunteer. A newsroom could produce a weekly communication check for its area. A university could study publishing habits over time. The method is the same for all of them, so two different groups can end up with the same picture.
The free kit now includes a small list of who sits above whom, so these views can be built from public files.
What this is not
- It is not a league table of delivery. It counts communication, not work.
- It is not a judgement on any person or party. No names are ranked and no motives are guessed.
- It is not proof of progress. Only the owner’s records can show what has actually been done.
- It is not a new legal duty. It is good practice, framed by section 195(1)(g) of the Constitution (transparency through timely, accessible and accurate information) and section 15 of the Promotion of Access to Information Act (voluntary disclosure).
Quick answers
What is a roll-up?
A roll-up counts and groups many projects from the same public records. It helps oversight bodies see patterns across a chain, a sector or a place. It creates no new reporting duty and asks nobody for new information.
Who can see the national picture?
Anyone who collects the published files can see it. That includes a newsroom, a university, a council, a resident with a spreadsheet, and the bodies at the top of the chains, DPME and the Presidency.
Does a low rank mean the work is bad?
No. The rank measures communication discipline only. A project with few updates may be working steadily, and its sign-offs and certificates are normally internal records. A missed update is a fact about communication, not about the work.
Does the municipality have to report upwards?
No. The municipality publishes its own records, and the roll-up reads them like anyone else. Escalation follows the owner’s own ladder. A comment on someone else’s project never changes the official status and never clears a flag.
Who builds the national view?
A daily job builds it from the small public file each body publishes, and anyone can write and run a job like it, because it only reads public files. There is no central database and nobody re-reports. Two different groups, working from the same files, can build the same view.
Is the dashboard on this page real data?
No. The demo uses about 1,900 sample projects with simulated figures. Any difference you see is chance, and it says nothing about how any real department or province communicates.
Next: doing it in-house, without a tender
Pass it on
If this makes sense to you, please send it to someone who works with project information, or to someone who will ask them for it.
Share this: WhatsApp · LinkedIn · Facebook · X · Email
The full article lives here; the conversation lives on Facebook. Tell us which project you would want updates on first.
Join the conversation on Facebook Follow FactSmith for the next articles
Work in a municipality or a department and want to try this on one project? Get in touch or book a 30-minute call. The kit is free under the MIT licence.
The figures in the demo are simulated. The first article, an appeal to whoever takes office, sets out the idea.